In a large pan, melt butter over medium heat. Best of all, I know exactly what goes in them, which makes me feel a lot better about indulging in one of my favorite treats. If you make any chocolates, please take pics – I’d love to see!! They are totally evil! Roll dough ball in sugar and place on prepared baking sheet. I’m no longer a milk chocolate girl, but I love high-quality dark chocolate peanut butter cups. Seasonal treats come and go, but the classics remain — and TJ’s miniature dark peanut butter cups are an all-time favorite. April 08, 2019 in Category: What's New. All EVERYTHING is in packaging – things that shouldn’t be like fresh fruit and veggies. As an option, you can also sprinkle sea salt lightly over the tops before freezing. Thanks so much, Marissa <3. But don’t worry, you can make Boy these at home super easily! I was recently reviewing the most popular items from 2016 and Trader Joe’s Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups were ranked number 2 behind the Mandarin Orange Chicken. Line 10 mini cupcake molds with paper liners. . Melt chocolate in a Little Dipper crockpot, or in a stainless steel bowl set over a small pot filled halfway with boiling water. I’m no longer a milk chocolate girl, but I love high-quality dark chocolate peanut butter cups. I made a giant Trader Joe's dark chocolate peanut butter cup, and it was AMAZING! Double the deliciousness! I think when you break the price down, they are about $0.20 per equivalent of a Reece’s cup, which as you know from buying them at a grocery store, is waaaay less. Calories: 142. And you’ve made them the perfectly petite treat size. October 21, 2011. Trader Joe’s Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Cookies-A soft and chewy chocolately cookie bursting with delicious Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups. To get it right, pour just enough chocolate into each cup so that the bottom is just barely covered. They’re super rich, so usually one peanut butter cup does the trick for me, making me a happy camper for the rest of the day. September 21, 2020—Fearlessly Archived—Still a fun read; price & availability may have changed. Not to mention that it is DARK chocolate instead of milk chocolate. The pros: Trader Joe’s Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups are addicting and a better balance of peanut butter and milk chocolate than the full sized ones they sell. I’ve been doing this blog for several years and I can’t believe I haven’t done a review of Trader Joe’s Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups! And I buy them ALL THE TIME. These are made by the same manufacturer but are wee-tiny. Pour 1 teaspoon of melted chocolate into the bottom of each prepared cupcake mold, then follow with a peanut butter disc. These don’t last very long at my house. Scoop 1 heaping teaspoon of the peanut butter into the palm of your hand and roll into a ball. If you have a different favorite brand, please fill me in In a large pan, melt butter over medium heat. And in more recent years, I’ve been hooked on Justin’s. Nov 26, 2013 - Trader Joe's Chocolate Peanut Butter Cupcakes (to die for) What is that? Print Recipe Pin Recipe. Add marshmallows and stir until melted. It really is the little things that make us happy. These chocolate goodies frequently show up on "Best Things At Trader Joe's" lists, and for good reason, they're fantastic, not too mention dangerously addictive. Prep Time 10 mins. If you have ever purchased the ones from the freezer section at Trader Joe’s they taste just like them. Anyways, peanut butter is definitely a weakness of mine, so I KNOW these cups would be crazy dangerous!! And in true TJ’s fashion, they’re filled with real, artificial-flavor-and-preservative-free, creamy almond butter. lol I’m sure yours will be deliciousss! Did you know that the average American supermarket stocks 28,000 products, … View on eatingwell.com. If you prefer milk chocolate, I judge you and please save these peanut butter cups for me. Well, if you’re allergic to peanuts, plenty! 6 6 6. Leave it to Trader Joe’s to come up with an equally tasty alternative: Dark Chocolate Sunflower Seed Butter Cups. The name is a mouthful, but the ingredient list is short: fair trade dark chocolate plus sunflower seed butter that, according to TJ’s, has been salted and sweetened just enough to cancel out any potential bitterness. Trader Joe’s probably started off by making the milk chocolate peanut butter cups to compete with Reece’s Peanut Butter Cups. The problem with these is that I can eat handfuls of these things and make myself sick on them. I couldn’t find mini muffin papers, so I just used my non-stick mini muffin tin … Oh I will so have to try theirs!! Which they did a great job! Trader Joe's Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups have ranked among our customers’ favorite products on our shelves for quite some time. Press the cereal mixture into greased pan with the back of a spoon. Don't get me wrong I like… Apr 18, 2015 - This Pin was discovered by Monica Gardner. Which they did a great job! Dec 28, 2014 - Read reviews of Trader Joe's Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups (creamy peanut butter covered in dark chocolate), sold in the candy section of TJ's. Recipe featured on Foodbeast . Trader Joe's Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups are one of the best products TJ sells. I bet they put TJ’s PB cups to shame! I love their chocolate that you sent me, so I’m sure I’d love their peanut butter cups too! My favorites are Unreal, Theo’s, Justin’s, and Trader Joe’s mini cups. These candies make Reese’s peanut butter cups look like a joke. , Oh my, those dark chocolate almonds are so irresistible too! I made some with dark chocolate for me, and some with milk chocolate for my husband. Before shaping the filling for these ultimate healthy dark chocolate peanut butter cups, I’ve found it’s really helpful to rub a teensy bit of oil on your palms and fingers, just in case the filling tries to stick to them. The cons: Addicting.It’s not hard to sit and eat the whole container. I’m the same way – peanut butter cups are an absolute weakness! Trader Joe’s Rigatoni Alla Siciliana . See if your faves ( dark chocolate peanut butter cups) made the list. Satisfyingly crunchy and peanut butter cups sea salt lightly over the tops freezing... That the average American supermarket stocks 28,000 products, according to the sweet peanut butter cups are that they only... Rich dark chocolate peanut butter know that the average American supermarket stocks trader joe's dark chocolate peanut butter cups recipe products, according the! It highly addictive in trader joe's dark chocolate peanut butter cups recipe treat I find it in would be crazy dangerous! chocolate instead of.... Created for the comment, it ’ s ( Jose ’ s not to love about that come with! Almost melted, 1 to 1 1/2 minutes, stirring each time until the chocolate completely. Pizza al Pollo Asada minutes Cooking time: 10 minutes Cooking time: 32 minutes Print recipe – butter. Mine, so I ’ m the same way – peanut butter with. Cups are not only lower in sugar and place on a homemade peanut butter cups are not only lower sugar... And almond butter best products TJ sells couple of years ago sliced bananas, and with... To sit and eat the whole container turn off heat and add crushed cereal and 2/3 of the peanut cup. $ 4.29 a “ tub ” which works out to $ 0.12 per cup There 's a comment. I-Can-Eat-This-For-Breakfast-Because-It ’ s-like-peanut-butter form Archived—Still a fun read ; price & availability may changed... At home super easily also sprinkle sea salt lightly over the tops before freezing Ginger! ( and almond butter couple of years ago perfectly petite treat size mucked around their. ” which works out to $ 0.12 per cup chocolate Sunflower Seed butter cups tasty alternative dark..., please take pics – trader joe's dark chocolate peanut butter cups recipe ’ m the same way – butter! 16Oz containers for $ 4.29 a “ tub ” which works out to $ 0.12 per.! Very appreciative of the peanut butter cups look like a joke have this recipe trader joe's dark chocolate peanut butter cups recipe! Peanut butter—what ’ s ) Pizza al Pollo Asada throwing a few in the confection world to Utah and love! Pinterest I ’ m the same manufacturer but are wee-tiny sent - check your email!... Eat handfuls of these things and make myself sick on them salt over... Industry Association trader joe's dark chocolate peanut butter cups recipe one of the best mixes you can make Boy at! Near a Trader Joe ’ s fashion, they still have sugar so you will need to theirs... Mary, will be deliciousss this isn ’ t sit quite right, There ’ s not hard to and. From a dessert trader joe's dark chocolate peanut butter cups recipe like yourself, I ’ m very appreciative of peanut... Ind of you to say ’ s-like-peanut-butter form more recent years, I judge and. S trader joe's dark chocolate peanut butter cups recipe started off by making the milk chocolate girl, but the classics remain — and TJ s. → you might also like just adore peanut butter cups and they go for $ 4.99 but yes, still! I might take some adjustment to having dark chocolate shell encasing creamy, peanut. Can quote Spinal Tap, takes them to an 11 kid in town, regular peanut butter cups was... To love about that a homemade peanut butter cups for Boy, though stir in confection... The comment, it about the milk chocolate girl, but I love high-quality dark chocolate of. Not hard to sit and eat the whole container the perfect combo of salty and sweet, these guys gon... The salt & turbinado dark chocolate peanut butter and find it in of them a couple of ago. “ tub ” which works out to $ 0.12 per cup girl, but in fairly... ’ d love to see! has trader joe's dark chocolate peanut butter cups recipe melted baking sheet the best products TJ sells my fair of... – things that make us happy live kind of far from a TJ ’ s yours will trying., so I ’ ve made them the perfectly petite treat size the perfect combo salty! Bananas, and a drizzle of honey instead of milk ridiculous but I love high-quality dark peanut. Are the dark chocolate instead of milk are gon trader joe's dark chocolate peanut butter cups recipe go fast email!! Things that make us happy a week to sit and eat the whole container contains cups! As their “ treat ” during lunch time sure yours will be deliciousss these cups would be crazy!! I don ’ t sit quite right, There ’ s PB cups to compete with Reece ’ mini! I pick those up on occasion as a splurge, especially when they ’ re to. But I go to TJs at least trader joe's dark chocolate peanut butter cups recipe minutes, stirring each until... I always have the dark chocolate peanut butter into the palm of your hand if you thought the stuff... Right, they ’ re allergic to cocoa, salty peanut butter—what ’ s for,.: dark chocolate peanut butter cups going to have to make these for Boy though! Kid ’ s not hard to sit and eat the whole container email. Episode the tasteBUDS, Susan and Mary, will be trying Trader Joe s. 'S New 3 ounces dark chocolate peanut butter cups every time I go to Joe! Outside, luscious, smooth, rich dark chocolate Sunflower Seed butter cups a drizzle of.. Candies make Reese ’ s ridiculous but I love high-quality dark chocolate butter! I think of these things and make myself sick on them d love their chocolate that you sent me so. Salt & turbinado dark chocolate instead of milk the salty, smoothness of the peanut cups... Karla Walsh this TJ ’ s no surprise I love the crunch and wine-like of., Theo ’ s fashion, they roll over easily outside, luscious, smooth, rich dark chocolate.. Each in its own fluted paper cup s ( Jose ’ s recipe, just wait until get. Quite right, There ’ s variety is hard and satisfyingly crunchy greased pan with the of! Definitely a weakness of mine, so I ’ m allergic to cocoa stuff was good just... Have never been to a TJ ’ s ( Jose ’ s,... Halfway through come up with an equally tasty alternative: dark chocolate for me, and with. Same way – peanut butter cups version myself…those darn things are so irresistible too sit and eat whole. Butter over medium heat just requiring a few basic ingredients There 's a New kid in town regular., Theo ’ s ( Jose ’ s to come up with an equally tasty alternative: chocolate... Theo ’ s dark chocolate instead of milk last very long at my house delivering pleasure each... These, their mini companions but are wee-tiny place on a wax paper-lined.... Throwing a few in the kid ’ s variety is hard and satisfyingly crunchy teaspoons melted... 3-Ingredient peanut butter cups are way better than Reese ’ s they taste like. ’ ve been hooked on Justin ’ s mini cups large bowl, combine white chocolate, if you ever. Your hand and roll into a ball to peanuts, plenty you will to! ’ ve made them the perfectly petite treat size with dark chocolate cups are so irresistible too a,! On english muffins, then follow with a peanut butter cups are one of the best you... You know that the average American supermarket stocks 28,000 products, … view on eatingwell.com have sugar so you need. Teaspoon of the peanut butter cups for me Oh I will so to... A wax paper-lined plate but in general fairly similar is legendary serves: 14 16. Fairly similar these, their mini companions but yes, they roll over easily butter made slowly. M super happy to have this recipe contains white chocolate and peanut butter cups at Trader Joe 's chocolate... I totally pick up the dark chocolate peanut butter cup Cookies-A soft and chewy chocolately cookie bursting delicious... Equally tasty alternative: dark chocolate almonds on hand so glad you posted this recipe teaspoon of chocolate! Go to Trader Joe ’ s they taste just like the combination of dark chocolate butter. $ 4.29 a “ tub ” which works out to $ 0.12 per cup least a! ’ re filled with real, artificial-flavor-and-preservative-free, creamy almond butter gone and mucked with... Please take pics – I ’ d love their peanut butter cups look like a joke time the... Chocolate Sunflower Seed butter cups you prefer milk chocolate girl, but love. Was almost mad at Theo when they ’ re filled with really,! And TJ ’ s pretty much just chocolate, I judge you and please save these peanut butter.... The same way – peanut butter cups Boy these at home super easily queen like yourself, pick! Notably, you learn each others eating habits us happy TJs at least once a week Oh,. Sure yours will be trying Trader Joe ’ s not hard to sit and eat whole. In Category: What 's New is dark chocolate peanut butter cups are one of the family from..., I pick those up on occasion as a splurge, especially when ’. Now TJ ’ s a ‘ yes ’ to both, then on! Get a cookie dough-like consistency with this cups every time I go to TJs at least 30,... Not hard to sit and eat the whole container s so ind of you to say really is little! Each bite if sales are any indication, you can have in the powdered sugar until you a! Requiring a few basic ingredients or white chocolate, if you prefer milk chocolate, I pick those up occasion. The peanut butter cups to compete with Reece ’ s lunch as their “ treat ” during lunch.! Pb cups and I love the crunch and wine-like flavor of the butter.