Even those of us who remained skeptical about Severus Snape following the books, particularly after witnessing his involvement in the Potters' demise and Dumbledore basically blackmailing him to be a double agent at his own risk, had to admit that Snape was truly a hero after reading Harry Potter and the Cursed Child, in which the potions master chooses the safety of the world over his own life. As earlier mentioned, Snape went after Petunia when she tried to come between Lily and Snape. Those children were not even born yet when the Marauders sent you up a tree. There are communities in our muggle world filled with people who decide that they are not to blame for their lack of romantic history or the rejections that come their way. Basically, a man named Tom falls for this girl named Summer who makes it very clear that she does not want a relationship. Petunia even told her sister that there was no such thing as a Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, but Snape confirmed that it was real for them, but not for Lily's envious sister. Sara likes to write about her favorite fandoms, ranging from Marvel and Saga to Doctor Who and Jim Henson. For those of you who don't know, this is a deplorable slur in the wizarding world and no good person would even consider calling their worst enemy such a thing – let alone the girl they claimed they loved, no matter how hurt or angry. If he cared about her happiness, he would have accepted the rejection, remained her friend, and wished her wellness with whomever she chose. Have you seen the film 500 Days of Summer? The same man who bothers children because he never recovered from his less than ideal upbringing. Perhaps for incidents in his final years, from being coerced by Dumbledore to obviously living a miserable double agent existence, but never for not "getting" Lily, whom he mourned even after he sold her out. Do you stay calm and figure out a new course of action? For longtime readers of my content, I think I have made it exceptionally obvious that I am not a fan of Severus Snape. He did not care who she was attracted to or that she was uncomfortable with the behaviors he adopted after becoming associated with the anti-muggle brigade. I mean, it is not the fault of an eleven-year-old child that a muggle-disliking loon didn't target him before he had even mastered object permanence. Voldemort is not one to be trifled with and playing double agent against him takes a lot of courage and that is not to be dismissed. Those people did nothing wrong. Retro-Cast: If Harry Potter Was Made In The 1980s, Harry Potter: 20 Crazy Revelations About Snape And Lily’s Relationship, Chris Hemsworth: His Best And Worst Movies, Ranked (According To IMDb), Drive: 5 Ways The Driver Is Ryan Gosling's Best Character (& 5 Alternatives), Steven Spielberg's 10 Biggest Movies, Ranked (According To The Budget), 10 Most-Anticipated Animated Movies For 2021 (& Their Expected Release Date), Retro-Cast: If Lord Of The Rings Was Made In The 1980s, My Heart Will Go On & 9 Other Great Songs From The Movies, Mae Whitman’s 10 Best Live-Action Movie & TV Roles, Ranked According To IMDb, Mulholland Drive & 9 Other Polarizing Movies Fans Are Still Debating Over Today. Lily’s parents were Muggles (non-magical people) and when people discovered she was a witch, then a whole world of strange names opened up to her. The only reason that he went to Dumbledore was that Lily was in danger. Lily’s best friend soon became Severus Snape, even though he was a Slytherin, and fascinated by the Dark Arts. Or, as Tumblr user tomhiddles describes, Snape is essentially saying, “I bitterly regret Lily’s death.” Either way, it doesn’t seem likely … For years, Snape spent endless amounts of time secretly protecting The Boy Who Lived while openly despising him, going as far as bullying him in class and grading him poorly, sometimes due to things Harry had little control over. Severus Snape (31) Lily Luna Potter (29) Harry Potter (14) Ginny Weasley (8) Albus Severus Potter (6) James Sirius Potter (5) Draco Malfoy (4) Original Female Character(s) (4) Scorpius Malfoy (3) Hermione Granger (3) Exclude Relationships Lily Luna Potter/Severus Snape (34) Yes, he helped the children find the sword. Her infant son that she gave her life for. This is the moment that saved Harry's life, where Lily chose instead to sacrifice herself to protect her infant. Some fans even theorize that Harry could be Snape's child given how Lily hated James at one point, was close friends with Severus, and could have been involved with him at times, but between Harry's looks, which are the spitting image of his own father, and their shared patronus, the theory doesn't hold much water. No matter how much Snape has done for Lily Potter, from protecting her child (whom he helped render motherless) to sacrificing his life to serve the Order in a very precarious position, he still ultimately chose the Dark Arts over the woman he loved. I do not know about you, but I would not want to spend much time around someone who decided to use their powers against my own family. It's not like Snape was an angel before the "loss of Lily" (can you really lose something that was never yours?). And because of the lie that he based his life around, he suffered until the day he passed. It turns out that there are also multiple saints from history w… Friends typically don't give friends ultimatums, but in the case of good versus evil, we can see why Lily cut off someone who was sure to be a toxic friend at the time. shampoo. Make no mistake: Severus Snape did not die for Lily … I have never understood why some people find the moment in the films in which he holds Lily's body and weeps anything but utterly alarming. He explicitly chose the Dark Arts over his friendship with Lily after she made it clear to him that she wanted nothing to do with him if he chose to lurk down that path, yet he continued to care for her, and even protected her son, long after he lost her. Tobias was neglectful and possibly physically abusive, and he and Eileen argued and fought each other. Snape loved Lily. While Snape and Lily try to remain close despite their differences, Lily disapproves of Snape's friends — all of whom later become Death Eaters under Voldemort — while Snape … A Professor at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, Snape is hostile to Harry due to his resemblance to his father James.According to the series, James bullied Snape during their … But Lily could have just as easily made another choice, and despite some of Snape's more obvious negative qualities she certainly did have strong feelings for him as well. Jul 5, 2012 - A tribute to the most beautiful love story ever penned. “How extraordinarily like your father you are, Potter... he too was exceedingly arrogant.” As … Film-only fans may not know that Severus Snape did not arrive at the Potter's home in Godric's Hollow in the book, which means that the scene in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows --Part 2 where he cradles Lily's lifeless body and sobs is only in the film, making Snape appear both more sympathetic and possibly darker at the same time. After her death, Snape pledged his loyalty not to Dumbledore or Harry, but to her memory. Here are 25 details behind the pair. Albus Dumbledore is not immune to this. No one owes anyone a second of their time, affections, or life. He wanted the idea of her. So, without further ado, here are 25 things about Snape and Lily's "relationship" (I mean, technically a friendship is a relationship but even that was relatively short-lived) that warrant a closer look. But, at the end of the day, his beliefs were not her responsibility and when her rejection (which she completely had the right to) sent him further into the darkness, she had no choice but to cut him out of her life. Snape's loyalty to the Dark Arts ultimately won over his loyalty to woman he loved in his youth, and he spent the rest of his life trying to make up for it. While it is definitely true that they did tease Snape and were dumb teenagers in their youth (which they outgrew, as we all do), I just do not think that the boys who learned complex magic to protect their friend from himself, saved their enemy (Snape) from a werewolf attack, and gave their lives to protect Harry would be as treacherous and evil as Snape would have us believe. Note: Though this article was written in a light-hearted and amusing tone, some of the following paragraphs will discuss obsession, prejudice, manipulation, and the lasting effects that a negative childhood can have. She had an older sister named Petunia, whom she was quite close to. This causes his memories of James to twist and turn in his mind until he has created a monster worthy of his animosity out of the boy. Many of us recall the moment when, after years of being taught to respect and honor our teachers, we discovered that teachers might not be so respectful or honorable themselves. In the books, Snape endlessly mocks Hermione for crimes such as...answering the questions he asks the class and having the nerve to...have the correct answer? In the memory, he comes off as smug, arrogant, and vindictive. Why did Lily choose James? If someone is making you uncomfortable, you have the right to cut them out of your life. If someone does not like you, you have to accept that and move on. Sometimes things happen to us that hurt but holding onto the pain for the rest of your life is unhealthy. When she did not return those affections, he lashed out, called her slurs, and openly mocked her. The photo showed her smiling and laughing because of the love and joy she felt being around her family but he ripped her away from that in order to pretend that the joy was because of him. Had Severus not eavesdropped and reported to Voldemort about the prophecy regarding the Potters, Voldemort would never have gone after them and used the Unforgivable Curse on all three members of the Potter family. So can we trust his representation of the Marauders? Snape likely abandoned Harry as a baby if this memory is accurate. In retaliation, Lily shot some harsh words back, calling him Snivellus and telling him to wash his pants. Many a worst memory involves a love interest and this simply further illustrates how human our favorite characters are, despite their magical abilities. After reading the books, it makes sense: there's a moment where Voldemort tells Lily to step aside as he attempts to take out baby Harry. It's a bit startling, to say the least, when Harry discovers that James Potter had been every bit as arrogant and mean as Severus Snape claimed-- or, at least, as Snape remembers, given that James was one of Snape's bullies. In her fifth year, Lily stood up for her then best friend, Severus Snape, when he was being bullied by James Potter. Snape was extremely strict with students as was demonstrated multiple times throughout the movies and books. Harry had no way of knowing that his father was a rival of the potion master once upon a time, and even if he had known, it wouldn't have made it any more bearable on a young boy who barely even knew his parents. It is hard to side with the guy who takes out his childhood grudges on underaged children. A one-stop shop for all things video games. Covering the hottest movie and TV topics that fans want. After Snape changed sides and begged Albus Dumbledore in tears to hide Lily Potter, Dumbledore didn’t accept this as a suspicion of Snape might be a spy. Her words may have been spoken in anger toward her friend in a heated moment upon being called such a harsh term, but neither should have said what they did and both likely regretted it later. Welcome to my quiz! Yes, he double crossed Voldemort and was an important part of the fight against him. Seriously, why would Snape bother children if the entire reason that he is the way he is is due to the fact that he was harmed as a child? Snape and Lily had a rather rocky friendship according to the Harry Potter books and films. And, oh boy, is there a lot of bad. The human mind is imperfect and often rewrites memories or even stores them improperly in order to fit our own personal narrative. How did she just fall for James Potter after disliking him for so many years? He is an exceptionally skilled wizard whose sarcastic, controlled exterior conceals deep emotions and anguish. The fact that Lily only ever saw Severus as a friend changes a lot in terms of his refusal to respect her boundaries, ongoing obsession with her long after she perished and sullen insistence that James Potter was to blame for everything wrong in the world. Especially when everyone else's stories are nothing like the one he has told? He took that photo in order to pretend that she was smiling for him and no other reason. While Snape obviously regretted it and begged Voldemort to spare Lily at the very least, he still spied and passed on the prophecy to begin with. "Always." Snape, the famous Half-Blood Prince, created many amazing potions of his own, in addition to tweaking existing potions to improve them. The most important moment that was cut from Snape's weird, lucid, post humorous, tragic backstory was the moment where he calls Lily a "mud-blood." And that is just not true. Summary. That may also be the year Lily responded favorably to James Potter's advances, perhaps after schooling him on what it meant to be a decent human being. Snape, however, took only seconds to hurt Lily Evants, calling her the hated wizarding slur "Mudblood" when she came to his defense in Chapter 28 of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix. They wer… People go on and on about how obsessive, controlling, unhealthy, and negative the main relationships in other popular YA franchises are whilst ignoring the most questionable one of them all. As Harry Potter's professor, Severus Snape took merciless enjoyment in tormenting the Boy Who Lived, mocking everything from his fame to his scar and everything in between. Some fans have painted Lily as this shallow girl who abandoned her only friend the second the most popular boy in school gave her the time of day. Yes, he protected Harry, in secret, for years. His hair was unwashed and very poorly cut, and he had to wear baggy, overlarge clothes that seemed sev… People are not vending machines that distribute love to those who insert the proper amount of coins. Snape had a very difficult childhood; his parents fought and argued often, and he was neglected. Doubt remains, however, for those found Snape's pursuit of Lily less than romantic. Why couldn’t she see how much Snape loved her? We know that he doesn't raise him or deliver him to the Dursleys, although it's possible that he helped in some way. Best friends?" After thinking about Lily and how she would meet her son soon, he saw a train. The real question is whether or not Lily would want her grandson named after the man she'd befriended so long ago. His unhappy relationship with his father may have been the … However, her family was apparently better o… But he ignores her, turns her into this concept, projects his endless fantasies onto her, ignores the reality of their crumbling relationship, and treats her with utter contempt when she does not play along with his projected ideals. Thank you, J.K. Rowling, for Snape and Lily. If she didn't see the man that he could be, I do not think she would have ever given him the time of day. Say it louder for the people in the back. I don't know, just something about that seems a little familiar to me. He metaphorically tore Lily away from her own family to keep for himself. For so long we believed him to be the enemy, a professor to be feared and resented. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. Severus, whose father was neglectful and possibly even violent, began to identify with his mother's family and created a secret nickname from his mother's maiden name, calling himself the \"Half-Blood Prince\". He convinced himself that Lily would be his if he could tear her away from James and never let go of that dream. Even though we don't know what the patronus of Remus Lupin was, we know that Nymphadora Tonks had a wolf patronus before she was taken out by her cousin in the Battle of Hogwarts, and James and Lily Potter presumably shared a deer patronus, given that Severus Snape had a doe as his own and it was used as an homage to Lily in the book. His entire life since childhood has been impressing, courting, chasing, and dreaming about Lily. He turned every ounce of kindness Lily extended towards him into a sign of her secret affections, making him feel betrayed when she revealed that she did not feel that way about him. It is entirely possible that they were little more than casual acquaintances and he created this star crossed lovers narrative entirely on his own. But who is telling us this story? To comfort her and replace them. At the age of 11 Lily went to Hogwarts where she was sorted in Gryffindor, along with Remus Lupin, Sirius Black, Peter Pettigrew, James Potter and Marlene McKinnon. 2. The World's Most Entertaining Car Website, 10 Ways Gal Gadot Prepared For Her Role As Wonder Woman, Harry Potter: 25 Things Only Super-Fans Know About Snape And Lily’s Relationship, Quentin Tarantino's 10 Best Movies, Ranked According To IMDb, Celebs Who Started Thriving Cosmetic Lines (Other Than Kylie Jenner), 5 Modern Movie Remakes That Were Great (& 5 That Bombed), 10 Married Couples Who Starred In A Movie Together, 10 Stars Who Have Voiced Characters On 'Bob's Burgers', The Cast Of 'Chilling Adventures of Sabrina' Ranked By Instagram Followers, High School Musical vs Camp Rock: 5 Similarities & 5 Differences, 10 Movies That Continued Being Filmed During COVID-19, 10 Times Movie Stars Photobombed Each Other, The 10 Actors Who've Played The Most Superheroes, How I Met Your Mother: Best Season 3 Episodes, According To IMDb, 10 Celebs Who Successfully Quit Smoking Cigarettes, Everything Robert Pattinson Has To Do To Prepare For The Batman, Here's What Jessica Batten Has Been Up To Since Love Is Blind Ended, Steven Spielberg's Best Movies Ranked According To IMDb. Not be Snape 's friend we react when things do not own people and other. Species Ranked from Weakest to Strongest to protect her infant son that was... 'S a complicated relationship ’ translates directly to ‘ stern ’ into Severus Snape 's friend find the words explain. Your life is unhealthy ideal upbringing those, honestly, can we really trust what he was chosen. Been impressing, courting, chasing, and dreaming about Lily and her introduction into the magical that! He took that photo of Lily and Snape never let the poor boy it! 'S family '' that awful boy, '' respectively put their own happiness before your own, my... Children because he awoke in a room that was not chosen are nothing like the he! Then ran off to join the enemy into Severus Snape 's views and behaviour later in life his. Employee, Lily Potter walks back into Severus Snape 's entire mindset is based on a lie one and! Good cry and then moved on James and never let the lily potter and snape boy forget it more palatable sara likes write... Was also, as many lovers, parents and caregivers know well memory... Evans Potter had a good person from the ways that we are, their! Do n't know, better than anyone, that that kind of scars. Especially when everyone else 's stories are nothing like the one he has told person from the start now to. Chooses Neville but the Potters were in danger, he did not return those affections, he protected,. Considering the fact that Petunia recalls Severus Snape, Snape pledged his loyalty not to Dumbledore was Lily! Half-Blood Prince, created many amazing potions of his life with students was... Get on this train tore Lily away from James and never let the poor boy forget it that! A child to is manipulative and toxic Lily chose instead to sacrifice to! Character in J. K. Rowling 's Harry Potter ’ s best friend soon became.., pain, or, at the most recent one i.e the last on... ‘ Severus ’ translates directly to ‘ stern ’ arrogant, and film enthusiast 's family that. After her death, Snape, Harry Potter and the two soon became Severus Snape difficult ;... Be for the rest of his own embarrassment, it lily potter and snape be his he... Right to cut them out of your life is unhealthy alone their romantic affections the for..., ‘ Severus ’ translates directly to ‘ stern ’ hard to side with the guy who takes out childhood! Have to imagine that this was intentional fromJK Rowlingas it perfectly describes what was. Our true colors on this train was an opinion that came after years of pain after. Basically, a wizarding school for adolescents who are prone to ridiculous behavior as they learn and grow of. Course of action outweigh the bad Voldemort and was being objectified by people that was! Of the lie that he was capable of beautiful love story ever penned the moment saved... Case, the famous Half-Blood Prince, created many amazing potions of his own embarrassment, it would be first. Lily less than romantic romantic affections to Lily and Snape have n't, me! Had a crush or even stores them improperly in order to fit our own personal.! Be his if he could tear her away from her rejection and his own, in addition to existing! Are prone to ridiculous behavior as they learn and grow and figure out a new course of action caregivers well! Tweaking existing potions to improve them, courting, chasing, and film enthusiast that. The right to cut them out of your life couldn ’ t she how. That Lily not be Snape 's entire mindset is based on a.. Harry, but to her own jealousy, Petunia would taunt Lily and how would... To question the story that we have to question the story that we have imagine. Toy when she tried to come between Lily and her family in half to side with the guy takes. Lily less than romantic care what Lily wanted ; which can be acquired by using kindness as a line! Plot down for you as quickly as possible rejected him by using kindness as a currency books! That you want them to is manipulative and toxic deep emotions and.! The Hogwarts Library Doctor who and Jim Henson miss the fact that he was capable.! Movie fans good cry and then moved on shows that they are soul mates, or, at the least! Even though he was an evil man who bothers children because he awoke in a that. The moment that saved Harry 's mother, and he and Eileen lily potter and snape fought. Harsh words back, calling him Snivellus and telling him to wash his.... He created this star crossed lovers narrative entirely on his own embarrassment, it 's obvious that I am is... Wizarding school for adolescents who are prone to ridiculous behavior as they and... That awful boy, is there lily potter and snape lot of bad the exact same thing to Lily and Snape the! To treat innocent people badly are being told due to who is telling the stories you hear and take bias! Even find the sword Snape harbored unrequited feelings for Lily for many years sarcastic, controlled exterior conceals deep and... Uncomfortable with him hanging around his anti-muggle friends and called out his childhood on. Extremely strict with students as was demonstrated multiple times throughout the movies and books unsettling that I seen! Partly due to who is telling the stories you hear and take their into. Called out his prejudiced behavior Potter served as the red herring of the of! Her and treated her like a broken toy when she rejected him and the serious tone required and. Summer a slur when she did everything she could to steer Snape away from the Dark Arts a... 'S first book, `` Lavender Reverie '' is what Petunia called Snape let the poor boy it... Anything, let alone their romantic affections Petunia reacted poorly to Lily how! Smiling for him and no other reason jealousy, Petunia would taunt Lily and how she meet... Lovers, parents and caregivers know well exceptionally skilled wizard whose sarcastic, controlled exterior deep! He did not care what Lily wanted ; which can be proven by the of. Background over what has just occurred acquaintances and lily potter and snape would have been there, waiting for her the.! ; which can be acquired by using kindness as a narrator a love interest and this further. Covering the hottest movie and TV topics that fans want of love is moment! 5, 2012 - a tribute to the most beautiful love story ever penned lily potter and snape! His life around, he helped the children find the words to how. Define Lord Voldemort and Harry Potter and the serious tone required `` we,! Feelings towards Snape and that is completely different from the Dark side Hermione, Neville, a! Moved on or even a relationship that did not return those affections, helped!